Reflections on the Reformation in the Cathedrals
When I am in Europe, I worship with the Roman Catholics. On a recent trip, my wife and I attended services in the cathedrals of three different cities–Salzburg, Vienna and Prague. Because I speak neither German or Czech, I didn’t get much out of the homily, but I did walk out of each service having learned something very important about our Lord and Saviour, His Grace, my faith, our worship–all of which have a little something to do with Protestantism and the Reformation.
Salzburg Cathedral – from exquisite beauty to holiness.
The interior of Salzburg Cathedral is beautifully ornate, but not gaudy. From my humble pew, I looked up and was overwhelmed. Part of that feeling, I think, was an encounter with holiness, through that exquisite beauty.
My church at home is very nice, but the priorities are different–utility and stewardship are the guiding principles for the physical building–and the comfort of the congregants. The seats in my home church are very comfortable, but even in the most beautiful of European cathedrals, one always sits on a very hard wooden bench. The seatback is set at almost 90 degreed to the seat and is capped with a board upon which the kneeling parishioner behind you can rest his elbows, so you can’t really lean back. These were definitely not designed with my comfort in mind.
It begins to dawn on me that very little thought has gone into my experience of this service.
The music that Sunday morning includes an organ, a small orchestra, and more than one choir. These are located behind and above me so I can’t see the musicians. Obviously, this performance is not for me–I am graciously allowed to listen in. In my home church, it’s not about me either, but the excellent praise band occupies the same place as would a performance band, so it’s very easy to think they are there for my listening pleasure. I sometimes forget they are not.
Pretty much everything in any church service is directed toward the worship of the triune God, but in Salzburg Cathedral, it was so much more obvious. The building and the music represent the very best of human achievement, and none of it was for me. That I was allowed to see, hear and enjoy them is pure grace.Everything in the church service is directed toward the worship of God, but in Salzburg Cathedral, it was so obvious. The building and the music represent the best of human achievement, and none of it was for me. That I can enjoy them is pure grace.Click To Tweet
St. Augustine in Vienna – where divine Grace intersects with nature
The Hapsburgs were christened, married and buried at St. Augustine so this cathedral has seen a lot of pageantry and ceremony over the years. The mass still reflects a polish and flair consistent with this history. I particularly noticed this in the treatment of the elements of the Eucharist.
In all Catholic services, the host, what we call, “the bread,” is treated with a great deal of respect. When congregants enter the door, they make the sign of the cross, and they genuflect before entering the pew. Both these actions are directed toward the host. Before, during and after the Eucharist, the actions of the officiating priest all reflect the veneration of the host. This reverence is seen in every Catholic service. In the mass at St. Augustine, all this was done with particular precision and flourish.
This elaborate treatment of the Communion elements is easily explained. Jesus Christ is present in the elements. From the New Testament until the sixteenth century, all Christians believed that those who partook of communion somehow received the body and blood of Jesus. Exactly how this happened was an unfathomable mystery, and according to the church fathers, it was supposed to remain that way. In 1215, against the warnings of the church fathers, the church accepted transubstantiation, that is, the conversion of the communion elements into the body and blood of Christ, as the explanation for Christ’s presence in the Eucharist. Protestants reject transubstantiation as the explanation for what happens in Communion, but some of us have duplicated the error of the Roman Church in 1215; we too attempt to explain “the unfathomable mystery.”
For many Modern evangelical congregations, the explanation for the unfathomable mystery is that there is no unfathomable mystery—the elements are just plain ol’ bread and wine. They are “just symbols” and the believe the entire point of the celebration of the Last Supper is to simply remember a past event. This explanation is a result of the modern tendency to separate the physical from the spiritual, to the detriment of both. The physical elements, then, are reduced to mere “crackers and juice,” and the spiritual dimension of the meal is reduced to mere remembrance.
What God did through the death and resurrection of Jesus is inseparably physical and the spiritual. The sacrament by which we remember this redemptive work is not simply a physical symbol, but also an actual spiritual event where Grace intersects with nature, in which a rational human eats and drinks in faith and so, encounters the divine.
Does that sound a little perplexing? It ought to be. That’s why it was called an “unfathomable mystery.” While I watched the Eucharist at St. Augustine, I was impressed with the mystery and wonder of it all. I thought I could bring some of this wonder to my own participation in the Lord’s Supper.The sacrament by which we remember Christ's redemptive work on the cross is not just a physical symbol, but also an actual spiritual event where Grace intersects with nature, in which a rational human eats and drinks in faith and so, encounters the divine.Click To Tweet
St. Vitus in Prague – The Kingdom of Heaven is not a democracy
St. Vitus has a commanding view of Prague. This Gothic structure stands within the castle complex situated on top of the city’s highest point, so it is visible from anywhere in the city.
This is the oldest of the cathedrals in which we worshiped on this trip; parts of the structure date back to the 14th century. The age of the church facilitated a connection to the medieval worshipers who also looked up into these same ceiling vaults.
I couldn’t what the priest was saying, so I looked at the windows.
Highest and most central in the central window was a depiction of God the Father embracing his crucified son. Beneath these dominant figures were haloed, major saints. All these figures were attended to by angels which were arranged according to their heavenly status. Beneath these were even smaller images of other saints. From my position in the pew, I looked up to them all, reinforcing my place in the hierarchy of the universe.
I’m way down here—the least of these.
This is a good position for a North American Protestant to be in every now and then. The window presents a medieval reality—a hierarchy. I am a product of the Reformation and the ensuing centuries. So is my church at home. I was recently disturbed to hear a church leader describe the Reformation as a holy response to church corruption. He implied that God’s endorsement of this step toward purity was certain. It is certainly true that corruption pushed Luther and others away from the Roman Church, but we tend to forget that it was also a movement toward something else. It was a step toward freedom—freedom from authority, and would eventually lead to one of our cultures most serious idolatries.
The Reformation was the first major step toward this freedom that continues to this day. Rebellion against the authority of the pope was followed by rebellions against monarchies in 1640, 1776 and 1789. In 1882, Nietzsche’s madman, declaring that “God is dead,” captured the spirit of our rebellion against the authority of God. The last century has seen freedom spread into all different directions—and some of these are very good directions. But have you noticed how much we talk about Freedom these days? We sing its praises between innings at baseball games and before NASCAR races— it is now linked with military power and has become the reason we have fought all our wars. Freedom–individual freedom—has become our god, submission has become sin. Any form of authority is evil—even that of our biology.
In the absence of this hierarchy, we have placed the autonomous individual at the top of a flattened, dark and lonely reality. This is why individualism ultimately leads to despair. Individualism dominates Western culture and has seeped into our churches as well. It is countered by the windows in St. Vitas. Looking up at the window I experience my smallness through awe, rather than loneliness, and see that the cosmos is full of light and love.Individualism has seeped into our Modern churches. It is countered by the windows in St. Vitas. Looking up at the window I experience my smallness through awe, rather than loneliness, and see that the cosmos is full of light and love. Click To Tweet
C. S. Lewis says that the medieval model, as presented in this stained-glass window, has a “serious defect,” that being “it is not true.” Nor, he goes on to say, is any model “true.”
The cathedral and mass do not necessarily represent a wholly true view of reality, but they do represent a different reality from the modern ideas that are woven into the fabric of our Protestantism. We might benefit from the admission that some aspects of worship in the cathedral do a little better job of engaging our imagination and allowing us to experience the significance of things.